DaVinci & Brava Roofing: Comparing Composite Shake and Slate

DaVinci and Brava composite roofing offer shake and slate-style textures. Compare each product’s appearance, installation requirements, ratings, and warranty before selecting a system.

Compare composite shake and slate appearance

Compare shake grain, slate texture, tile widths, color blends, and the finished ridge details. A small sample helps with color; a completed roof is more useful for judging the overall pattern.

See a UV Exteriors DaVinci slate-style roof in South Barrington for a real project example.

Ask about the installation system

• Which exact product and accessory pieces are specified?
• What roof slope, deck, underlayment, and fastening requirements apply?
• How will valleys, roof penetrations, and roof-to-wall flashing be handled?
• Are any structural assessment, ventilation changes, or snow-management details needed?

Compare complete roof proposals

Ask for the exact shake or slate product in each estimate, together with its color blend and accessory pieces. A brand name alone does not tell you which roof has been priced.

• Appearance: compare the field pattern, edges, and ridge treatment.
• Scope: identify removal, deck preparation, flashing, and disposal.
• Future repairs: ask how replacement pieces would be sourced and who to contact for service.

Use the South Barrington photos to discuss the overall look, then request samples for your own exterior. A completed DaVinci project should not be presented as an example of a different manufacturer’s product.

Compare ratings without treating them as guarantees

Ask for the test ratings that apply to the selected product and assembly. A wind, fire, or impact classification is not a promise that a roof cannot be damaged. Manufacturer instructions and site conditions still matter.

Review ownership costs and warranty terms

Compare the installation price, inspection and maintenance needs, repair availability, and the actual warranty document. A long warranty term does not establish a guaranteed service life or mean every labor cost is covered. Brava's slate installation guide illustrates the importance of product-specific instructions and warranty registration.

Browse roofing styles and selections or request a comparison for your home.